Why not use Silicon ?
#1
07-12-16, 12:35 PM
Why not use Silicon ?
I am just a DIY-er.... often I'd read instructions or watch a clip on youtube how to do something and then I follow the "procedure".
However, I do like to also learn why things are done in a particular way and so just last few days, when doing a new bath tub / shower setup and using several of Copper threaded connections, I wondered..... The technique is to put a Teflon tape on the thread and screw on the connection, but why nobody thought of finishing up with a bit of Silicon ??
Especially considering that those connections are behind a wall and hard to access in the future - I'd imagine that providing maximum security and prevent a failure of the connection would be critical.
I realize that threaded connection with tape or dope if done properly shouldn't ever leak but considering that it takes only 30 more seconds and is cheap - why not finish with a dab of Silicon ??
would there be any harm in doing so ?
However, I do like to also learn why things are done in a particular way and so just last few days, when doing a new bath tub / shower setup and using several of Copper threaded connections, I wondered..... The technique is to put a Teflon tape on the thread and screw on the connection, but why nobody thought of finishing up with a bit of Silicon ??
Especially considering that those connections are behind a wall and hard to access in the future - I'd imagine that providing maximum security and prevent a failure of the connection would be critical.
I realize that threaded connection with tape or dope if done properly shouldn't ever leak but considering that it takes only 30 more seconds and is cheap - why not finish with a dab of Silicon ??
would there be any harm in doing so ?
#2
07-12-16, 01:50 PM
Member
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: U.S.
Posts: 4,807
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Silicone should never be used on plumbing connections, especially pipe threads. It won't harm the pipes, but it serves no purpose.
The most common misuse I see is on kitchen drain pipes. Someone thought it would help and it might or might not.
On pressurized water it's useless. That's what tape and dope are for.
The most common misuse I see is on kitchen drain pipes. Someone thought it would help and it might or might not.
On pressurized water it's useless. That's what tape and dope are for.
#3
07-12-16, 06:41 PM
just to clarify...I didn't mean to put Silicone on the entire threads where the connection occurs but rather to "seal off" the final outer connection made between the male and female connectors.
Tape would still be used.
For me the idea came because of the "fear" and guessing if I am tightening the connection enough but not to the point of over-tightening and damaging the threads.
Tape would still be used.
For me the idea came because of the "fear" and guessing if I am tightening the connection enough but not to the point of over-tightening and damaging the threads.
#4
07-12-16, 06:52 PM
Group Moderator
Silicone isn't going to stop water that's under pressure, so putting silicone on the outside of a pipe connection is pretty pointless. The only time silicone should be used is where it's for a gasket type of application. Like under a faucet flange that has no rubber gasket or when installing a sink basket. Silicone has no place on supply lines.
#5
07-12-16, 08:11 PM
Member
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: U.S.
Posts: 4,807
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
just to clarify...I didn't mean to put Silicone on the entire threads where the connection occurs but rather to "seal off" the final outer connection made between the male and female connectors.
If you are not over tightening to the point of breaking something you are doing good. A taped and doped joint needs to be tight, but don't get carried away.
