A cedar shingle roof continues to be highly coveted by homeowners. It is one of the oldest roofing materials which has remained constantly in use over the centuries. As much as new roofing materials continue to be developed, cedar shingles still endear themselves to many. Below is a comparative analysis of a cedar roof versus an asphalt roof.
Pros of Cedar Shingles
Cedar shakes contribute to improved air circulation within the entire house. The shakes allow the house to breathe well without trapping moisture within. This helps to maintain the structure of the house in good condition for longer. Cedar shingles are durable and resilient. They enjoy a high resistance to bugs. A cedar shingle roof will stand up well to the various weather onslaughts. Storms, hurricanes, strong winds and flying debris will hardly damage the surface of your cedar roof. The color matures beautifully with the passing years, making it all the more desireable. A cedar roof adds a distinct charm to your home. Cedar is readily available in lumber yards and doesn't require a lot of expertise or specialized tools to install.
Cons of Cedar Shingles
If rot sets in, you'd be compelled to replace the entire lot. It is not easy extracting just the affected pieces. They may have been nailed down in such a way that individual elimination proves difficult. Cedar shingles don't hold up well to constant wetting. If you live in an area where rainfall is heavy or frequent, cedar shingles aren't the ideal choice. Frequent wetting causes mold or mildew to set in. Replacement and repair can be a costly business. Your best protection against constant wetting would be to use wide overhangs. Also, if your house is shaded by many trees or nearby buildings, cedar shingles tend to develop mildew. You will be compelled to replace them sooner than you planned. Cedar shingles are more flammable than asphalt shingles. Many areas have a building code in place that restricts cedar shingles to reduce the risk of fire. To install a cedar shingle roof, you need to have your budget on the higher side. Frequent maintenance is also necessary to keep the roof in good shape. Mold and rot are ever-constant threats to a cedar roof.
Pros of Asphalt Shingle Roof
An asphalt roof is one of the most affordable to purchase and install. They are available in various designs and colors, ranging from a plain, flat look to a 3-dimensional look. Asphalt shingles enjoy a high resistance to fires unlike cedar roofing. An asphalt roof can actually reduce the risk of fires caused by flying embers. Asphalt roofs are easier and cheaper to install than cedar. They are also low maintenance roofs.
Cons of Asphalt Shingle Roof
Algae is more likely to grow on asphalt roofing than cedar shingles. It causes the roof to develop somewhat of a stain which spoils the appearance. You can get an anti-algae coating done on your asphalt shingles but this adds to the cost. In terms of stability, an asphalt roof is more likely to be blown off by strong winds than a cedar roof.