Fiberglass Garage Doors vs Vinyl Garage Doors

Although they’re a more recent material, fiberglass garage doors are now fairly common. Traditionally, the more common materials used have been steel, aluminum and wood. Another recently introduced material for garage doors is vinyl. Homeowners are increasingly turning to these two recent entrants for garage door needs. You may be wondering which makes a better choice between fiberglass and vinyl. Fiberglass consists of extra-fine sheets of glass, compressed together into a solid material. Vinyl is manufactured from PVC resin to yield highly durable plastic for various uses. Below is a general comparison of the two materials.

Pros of Fiberglass Garage Doors

Fiberglass garage doors are translucent. This makes them an ideal choice where light transmission is vital. Some people prefer to use natural light while in the garage. Fiberglass is highly resistant to peeling, especially that caused by salt-air corrosion. This makes it ideal for garage doors in seaside locations. Fiberglass is more versatile than vinyl. It can be produced to resemble wood grain material, yet is more durable than wood. You can get fiberglass in various designs that will blend with different architectural styles. Fiberglass garage doors can also be painted if you so wish.


Fiberglass exterior doors cost a fair amount. This may serve as a deterrent to acquisition. Fiberglass exterior doors dent easily. Should they dent, you most likely will be looking at replacement. This adds to home maintenance costs. They also have a weaker resistance to breakages as they age. This may detract from their durability. The regular maintenance required for fiberglass doors also adds to overall costs involved.

Pros of Vinyl Garage Doors

It is less costly to produce vinyl than fiberglass. This makes vinyl garage doors more affordable. Vinyl has good insulation properties. When used on garage doors it makes the home more energy efficient. This can give you some savings on energy bills. Garage doors made of vinyl will not dent, peel or rot. Vinyl garage doors are also low maintenance. Vinyl has a high resistance to moisture and humidity. In areas where the weather is frequently wet or humid, vinyl garage doors are a good choice. Vinyl can be recycled up to 100 percent. Less natural resources and energy are needed to manufacture vinyl. It also releases minimal emissions into the atmosphere. This makes vinyl more environmentally friendly than fiberglass.


Vinyl garage doors aren’t as durable as those made of fiberglass. Vinyl is susceptible to damage caused by certain weather changes. Warping is a frequent problem where frequent temperature fluctuations occur. Cold weather has a negative impact on vinyl garage doors. It causes the garage doors to become more noisy than usual. Vinyl is highly combustible. Garage doors made of vinyl can well fan damage to the house in the event of an accidental fire. It is important to consider this, especially if you live in a fire-prone area.